Vendors must establish a reserve price before bidding opens, determine their strategy for pre-auction offers, and set a strict post-auction walk-away price. With 35–40% of Melbourne properties currently passing in (CoreLogic/Cotality/Domain/PropTrack/REIV/RBA/ATO), a clear negotiation plan for when the reserve is not met is essential.
The choice between an auction and a private sale depends on current clearance rates and property location. In a market where Melbourne’s clearance rate has dipped to 59.1% (CoreLogic/Cotality/Domain/PropTrack/REIV/RBA/ATO), the risk of a property passing in is higher than in previous years.
Setting the reserve price
Victorian law requires the vendor and agent to agree on a reserve price before bidding opens. If bidding reaches this figure, the property is “on the market” and sells unconditionally to the highest bidder.
Handling pre-auction offers
Agents are required to present all offers to the vendor during the campaign. You must decide whether to accept a strong pre-auction offer immediately or risk the property passing in to seek a higher result through competitive bidding.
The post-auction negotiation strategy
If a property passes in, the highest bidder has the first right to negotiate privately under CAV rules (CoreLogic/Cotality/Domain/PropTrack/REIV/RBA/ATO). Vendors should establish a firm walk-away price before auction day to avoid accepting offers anchored below the reserve.
The pass-in anchor
When a property does not sell on the day, buyers often perceive the vendor’s position as weaker. This frequently leads to buyers attempting to anchor their private offers below the reserve price, regardless of the agent’s framing.
| Metric (Week ending 11 April 2026) | Current Value | Previous Week | Same Week 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Melbourne Clearance Rate | 59.1% | 61.4% | 66.8% |
| Median House Price | $937,500 | $1,021,000 | $1,001,000 |
| House Clearance Rate | 57.2% | N/A | N/A |
| Unit Clearance Rate | 59.1% | N/A | N/A |
Source: (CoreLogic/Cotality/Domain/PropTrack/REIV/RBA/ATO)
Frequently asked questions
What happens if my property passes in at auction?
If the reserve is not met, the property is “passed in.” Under CAV rules, the highest bidder is granted the first right to negotiate privately with the vendor. Most properties that pass in sell via private negotiation within a few weeks (CoreLogic/Cotality/Domain/PropTrack/REIV/RBA/ATO).
Is an auction sale unconditional?
Yes. Auction sales in Victoria are unconditional, meaning there is no cooling-off period. Contracts are signed on the day of the auction, and a deposit, typically 10%, is paid immediately by the purchaser. Settlement generally occurs between 30 and 90 days later.
Should I choose a private sale over an auction?
Private sales are favoured for properties on the Mornington or Bellarine Peninsulas, high-end homes above $3–4 million, or when clearance rates are below 60% (CoreLogic/Cotality/Domain/PropTrack/REIV/RBA/ATO). It is also preferred for tenanted properties or when selling to interstate and overseas buyers.
How much does an auctioneer cost?
Auctioneer fees typically range between $400 and $1,000. These costs are often bundled into the overall marketing package agreed upon at the start of the campaign.
Questions to ask your agent
- Given the current 59.1% clearance rate, what specific data suggests an auction will outperform a private sale for my property?
- If the property passes in, what is the immediate communication strategy to prevent buyers from anchoring their offers below our reserve?
- How does the current buyer profile in my eastern suburb corridor differ from the broader Melbourne median house price of $937,500?
This article contains general market information based on data current as at April 2026. It does not constitute financial, legal, or real estate advice specific to your property or circumstances. For an appraisal and tailored advice, speak with a Fletchers agent in your area.