Rental application rejections are a common experience for prospective tenants, particularly in competitive markets like Melbourne. As of December 2025, a high volume of applications for each property means standards are often very high, and multiple strong applicants may miss out.
Currently in Melbourne, particularly within the Eastern Suburbs – areas like Balwyn, Doncaster, and Ringwood – several factors contribute to rejections. Property managers often prioritise applicants with a strong rental history, demonstrated financial stability (verified income and savings), and positive references from previous landlords. Complete applications are essential; missing information automatically disadvantages an applicant. In 2026, we’re seeing increased emphasis on the applicant’s ability to demonstrate long-term tenancy, with landlords favouring those seeking leases of 12 months or more. Competition is also heightened by demographic trends; demand for family homes near schools in areas like Maroondah is consistently strong. While not directly related to selling, this illustrates the competitive nature of the Melbourne property market overall. Fletchers’ experience shows that well-presented properties attract a larger pool of qualified applicants, mirroring the importance of presentation when preparing a home for sale. The typical campaign duration for a property sale is 4-6 weeks, and a strong initial presentation is vital to attract buyer interest.
Ultimately, a rental rejection often reflects the sheer volume of applications and the landlord’s need to minimise risk, highlighting the importance of a thorough and complete application.